Launching the CI/CD and R Collectives and community editing features for How to know the Physical Application Path in Window Azure? The IP address of the client device. PTIJ Should we be afraid of Artificial Intelligence? This is happening across several resource groups and several deployment slots, and I haven't uploaded new versions in this period. If you experience the error shown in the preceding screenshot, you can resolve it. We decide the name of our Application Insights Table with its columns. Azure Portal: Application Insights - How to Identify Requestor's IP Address, Application Insights .NET or .NET Core SDK, The open-source game engine youve been waiting for: Godot (Ep. So if the clients of your application are using IPv6 IP address will not be send to Application Insights. Unfortunately all previous requests will remain scrubbed with 0.0.0.0. I already have a filter running that I added via addTelemetryProcessor, but the envelope I get there doesn't have those fields, they must be added at some later point in the pipeline. Troubleshooting guide. "Microsoft.ApplicationInsights.Web.ClientIpHeaderTelemetryInitializer, Microsoft.AI.Web". You can set a list of header names to check, separators to split IP addresses and whether to use first or last IP address. You can configure the ClientIpHeaderTelemetryInitializer to take the IP address from a different header. The default client-ip column will still have all four octets zeroed out. Sign in The IP addresses limit in order to track if the subnet is reaching out his number of available IP addresses >. Different data sources treat client IP field in different approaches. Add a comma to the last JSON field, and then add the following new line: "DisableIpMasking": true. The Advanced Logging module can be installed and configured on your Client Access servers and enables you to configure a log definition that includes the X-Forwarded-For IP address details. This is why you may find some fake Brazilian clients when your application was deployed in Azure. This does not You can tell this by the line: To know your in the right place, under properties there will be many values, we should see Application_Type, InstrumentationKey, ConnectionString, Retention, but what will be missing is DisableIpMasking. The link to the official service announcement is not working anymore. If that one succeeds, the changes made to DisableIpMasking were deployed. If you've already registered, sign in. The telemetry types are: Browser telemetry: We collect the sender's IP address. This is a known issue and we have confirmed with the corresponding product team. to your account. Application Insights Agent configuration is needed only when you're making changes. Client IP address Reviewing the property values for ApplicationInsightsComponentProperties object DisableIpMasking gave the following short but sweet answer. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. The number of IP addresses that are used. Well occasionally send you account related emails. Add the subdomain of the corresponding region to the Live Metrics URL from the Outgoing ports table. This For more information, see, Provide your own custom initializer. A service tag represents a group of IP address prefixes from a specific Azure service. This breaks down a bit when the instrumented application is actually the user itself as I believe we fallback to the "server" IP address (eg. Caveat here is that Application Insights only supports IPv4 at the moment of this writing. Workaround: Enable Azure Monitor log in Application Gateway side and get client IP from there. For example, in the following screenshot we can see that: Azure Application Insights has an endpoint where all incoming telemetry is processed. You may currently be seeing the IP 0.0.0.0 in logs, which is the default: This behavior is by design to help avoid unnecessary collection of personal data. affect data collected prior to February 5, 2018. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. The *.applicationinsights.io domain is owned by the Application Insights team. Replace the missing values accordingly, Second, use a custom TelemetryInitializer, And than don't forget to register the type with the DI container, The IP address will show up as a custom dimension, https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/azure/azure-monitor/app/data-model-context#client-ip-address. You can: To enable IP collection and storage, the DisableIpMasking property of the Application Insights component must be set to true. This telemetry initializer will check X-Forwarded-For http header and if it is not set - use client IP. Temporarily select a different resource group from the dropdown list and then re-select your original resource group. I'm using app insights to add telemetry to our VS Code extensions. By default, IP address calculation for client-side telemetry occurs at the ingestion endpoint in Azure. This process follows some basic steps. Find centralized, trusted content and collaborate around the technologies you use most. You will be shown the JSON definition of your Application Insights Object. Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community. Any way to track it via Azure Portal site ? You may still submit IP as a custom property (if required) via Telemetry Initializers available in most AI SDKs, however, this moves responsibility over handling that IP as well. The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: A telemetry processor is the correct way to disable collection of "user" IPs from a traditional server point of view. The source IP address and port number of the package is internal. Let's take TCP protocol for instance, SNAT works in the following steps: An App Service application sends a TCP package to an Internet IP address. Open port 80 (HTTP) and port 443 (HTTPS) for incoming traffic from these addresses. Visit Microsoft Q&A to post new questions. Microsoft takes a great care to help manage and protect personal data that can be collected in Azure Log Analytics. Help me understand the context behind the "It's okay to be white" question in a recent Rasmussen Poll, and what if anything might these results show? The following regions are not supported yet, but will be added in the near future. Azure Application Insights - capture client IP, For example Azure Application Insights by default obfuscates all IP address fields to "0.0.0.0". Find centralized, trusted content and collaborate around the technologies you use most. rev2023.3.1.43268. Weapon damage assessment, or What hell have I unleashed? An API request seems like the quicker request method, but doing this in a script with authentication and correct structure takes time. Wasn't that supposed to stop in February or could there be something else going on? Sharing best practices for building any app with .NET. Although the default is to not collect IP addresses, you can override this behavior. All my requests logged on application insights have the 0.0.0.0 IP. To avoid this you can make SDK submit dummy IP like "0.0.0.0" with telemetry processor/initializer, then AI Endpoint will take that value over the sender IP (this will lead, however, to inability to extract City and other location info from such address). As long as the Application Insights .NET or .NET Core SDK is installed and configured on the server to log requests, you can create/update an Application Insights resource on Azure that shows the client's IP address. We schedule the audit! As long as the Application Insights .NET or .NET Core SDK is installed and configured on the server to log requests, you can create/update an Application Insights resource on Azure that shows the client's IP address. We will track our Azure Virtual Network IP addresses consumption but note that after reading this article you will be able to track any kind of information. If you can't access ISupportProperties, make sure you're running the latest stable release of the Application Insights SDK. At the same time you own your application. If you've already registered, sign in. If you aren't seeing IP address data and want to confirm that "DisableIpMasking": true is set, run the following PowerShell commands: A list of properties is returned as a result. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. Transparency For transparency, two rules must be followed: The clients must be on a different subnet to the Real Server The Real Server's default gateway must be the LoadMaster's interface address This is a known issue, and the APIM product team already has a work item to discuss the possibility to modify this. Manually log the "X-Forwarded-For" header in APIM Application Insights. Is that what is happening, i.e. I have a web app running in Azure and I'm using Application Insights Analytics to look at the incoming requests. This is a known issue and we have confirmed with the corresponding product team. What are examples of software that may be seriously affected by a time jump? What is the arrow notation in the start of some lines in Vim? Browse other questions tagged, Where developers & technologists share private knowledge with coworkers, Reach developers & technologists worldwide. Country, state and city information will be extracted from it and than the last octet of IP address will be set to 0 to make it non-identifiable. Which intern has authenticated you to the API using your existing login token, constructed the JSON object and is sending a POST method to the API endpoint for management.azure.com/subscriptions//resourceGroups//providers/microsoft.insights/components/?api-version=2015-05-01. In this article we will demonstrate how to send custom event telemetry to an Azure Application Insights instance through PowerShell. If App Insight is showing Client IP as 0.0.0.0: The default behavior for App Insight is to mask the IP field and display it as 0.0.0.0. In the next article (part 2) we will see how to automate the audit through an Azure Function App. If you send new traffic to your site and wait a few minutes, you can then run a query to confirm that the collection is working: Newly collected IP addresses will appear in the customDimensions_client-ip column. This article explains how geolocation lookup and IP address handling work in Application Insights, along with how to modify the default behavior. The address is then discarded, and 0.0.0.0 is written to the client_IP field. And Microsoft provides capability to accommodate this requirement with ease. If you run the PowerShell commands before you deploy the new property with Azure Resource Manager, the property won't exist. We decide what we want to audit - > Subnet IP adresses consumption. I have no idea yet of how these instances might influence each other. How are we doing? This is relatively easy to do, however it means an additional set of IIS logs is being generated on your server that you'll need to manage. but still translating to a geolocation?!? Otherwise, register and sign in. GlobalProperties is more appropriate for low cardinality values like region name and environment name. As we can see in the screenshot, the client IP column here is App Gateways private IP instead of end users actual client public IP. Function App will extract this IP and send this to App Insight. upcoming GDPR law in EU. Using serilog with azure application insights and .Net core. Starting February 5, 2018, Application Insights will set all octets of the IP address collected by client/server side SDKs to Zero after looking up the City, Country and other geo location attributes. If we test the request and check the APIM trace, we will see when APIM forwards the request to Function App, there are two IP addresses in the X-Forwarded-For header, and the first one is the actual end users public IP. Telemetry Initializers available in most AI SDKs, however, this moves responsibility over handling that IP as well. To capture the IP addresses of clients in your web server access logs, configure the following: For Application Load Balancers and Classic Load Balancers with HTTP/HTTPS listeners, the X-Forwarded-For HTTP header captures client IP addresses. You can create your telemetry initializer the same way for ASP.NET Core as for ASP.NET. How to set dummy IP via telemetry processor. Already on GitHub? Details: When ai.location.ip is set, the ingestion endpoint doesn't perform IP address calculation, and the provided IP address is used for the geolocation lookup. As this value only seems to be exposed through the API we have to either push a new incremental ARM template through the sausage maker or perform a API request directly. APIM will send incoming resource's IP as client IP to App Insight. You might need to know IP addresses if the app or infrastructure that you're monitoring is hosted behind a firewall. And I guess I'd really also like to not collect City and "State or province". Please choose a different resource group." If IP appeared for some time in the telemetry again, that must've been a temporarily glitch that has been addressed. The IP masking feature of Application Insights can be disabled. For anyone who ends up here in the future, they do have a list of ip address used by application insights available here: https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/azure/application-insights/app-insights-ip-addresses There are a ton more on the documentation page but here are the main telemetry IP's it uses: 40.114.241.141 104.45.136.42 40.84.189.107 Proudly created with Wix.com. Dealing with hard questions during a software developer interview, How to choose voltage value of capacitors, Applications of super-mathematics to non-super mathematics. Please help us improve Microsoft Azure. By clicking Post Your Answer, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. Action group service tag Managing changes to source IP addresses can be time consuming. strengthens privacy and is a change from the prior processing that set By clicking Post Your Answer, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. Select Service Tag as the Source and ApplicationInsightsAvailability as the Source service tag. For Live Metrics, it is required to add the list of IPs for the respective region aside from global IPs. The reference documentation is available here: Application Insights API for custom events and metrics. Great answer - just a shame Microsoft fail to let us know before making a change - wastes so much time when you think you've misconfigured something. The ::1 value represents the loopback address in IPv6. You may currently be seeing the IP 0.0.0.0 in logs, which is the default: Now we can observe that older records have client IP masked and new AI records contain actual client IP values. @Dmitry-Matveev if I recall, you were looking at potentially user-identifying data like IP address. You can then configure your web server access logs to record these IP addresses. As an example, an entry like 51.144.56.112/28 is equivalent to 16 IPs that start at 51.144.56.112 and end at 51.144.56.127. - Using .Net Core 2 To remove geolocation data, see the following articles: Remove the client IP initializer Use a custom initializer Hello i was wondering if someone could answer this question for me: Is there a way for me to view logs of incoming requests and their IP Addresses. This forum has migrated to Microsoft Q&A. Download US Government cloud IP addresses. When IP addresses aren't collected, city and other geolocation attributes populated by our pipeline by using the IP address also aren't collected. Client IP address is useful for some telemetry scenarios. Another tip - C# SDK do not allow to sent IPv6 addresses to Application Insights. Also in record detail we now can correlate client IP will all other information captured in AI. But again, unlike the server-side SDKs, the client-side SDK won't calculate the address for you if it can't rely on third-party libraries or your own custom logic. Track IP addresses consumption with Azure Application Insights Part1, //westeurope-3.in.applicationinsights.azure.com/;LiveEndpoint=https://westeurope.livediagnostics.monitor.azure.com/>, 'Specify the connection string of your Azure Application Insights instance. To remove geolocation data, see the following articles: This behavior is by design to help avoid unnecessary collection of personal data and IP address location information. I have a nice trick when wanting to update or add a value to an object when either of those feel like overkill. The address is then discarded, and 0.0.0.0 is written to the client_IP field. Description that esassaman provided applies only to US. If we aren't around we'll still get the message, latest API version for Microsoft.Insights/components, property values for ApplicationInsightsComponentProperties object, Find the Application Insights Resource Group, Remember to add a , to the previous last line (in my case . Application Insights FAQand the One of the machine's configuration is pointing to a correct domain, but the wrong controller name. Weapon damage assessment, or What hell have I unleashed? # Convert the body object into a json blob. Azure Monitor is a service in Azure that provides performance and availability monitoring for applications and services in Azure, other cloud environments, or on-premises. # App Insights has an endpoint where all incoming telemetry is processed. It's equivalent to 127.0.0.1 in IPv4. We need to track the number of IP addresses that are used on our subnet, to do that we will need to send custom event telemetry with the following information: With those information being tracked on a regular basis we will be able to graph our IP addresses consumption. Upgrade to Microsoft Edge to take advantage of the latest features, security updates, and technical support. Can you provide a working link? This is by design because of GDPR. We noticed that all the client GET requests had 0.0.0.0 in Client IP Address. Find out more about the Microsoft MVP Award Program. Similar rules are applied for IPv6 data (though with many more segments removed due to IPv6 potentially being more identifiable). I would like to identify which machine is configured wrongly by identifying the IP Address of the incoming request that is causing this issue. To enable the initializer, use the following example for reference: Unlike the server-side SDKs, the client-side JavaScript SDK doesn't calculate an IP address. Application Insights uses the results of this lookup to populate the fields client_City, client_StateOrProvince, and client_CountryOrRegion. SNAT changes the source IP and port of the TCP package . Popular one is X-Originating-IP. 2018 by Cloud Matter. Resources like Function App for example, extracts the end users IP addresses from the X-Forwarded-For request header. Applications of super-mathematics to non-super mathematics. One of the properties should read DisableIpMasking: true. @davidanthoff , the last octet of IPv4 (and IPv6) is currently removed for privacy reasons. Yep, IP should've stopped flowing in February. Youll be auto redirected in 1 second. Why? This telemetry initializer will check X-Forwarded-For http header and if it is not set - use client IP. For example Azure Application Insights by default obfuscates all IP address fields to "0.0.0.0". @nidhi5885 Application Gateway is the client when looking from the perspective of the backend server and its IP address will be treated as the client IP address for all network packets and access logs. 1 comment diepnt90 commented on Aug 31, 2020 List of NuGet packages and version that you are using: Pre-Installed Site Extension, version 2.8.37.4238, is running We are funnelling all the request logs into an Application Insights services to manage visibility of the end-to-end transaction data. It is easy to override the default logic of ClientIpHeaderTelemetryInitializer using configuration file. Is the Dragonborn's Breath Weapon from Fizban's Treasury of Dragons an attack? The format for x-forwarded-for header is a comma-separated list of IP:Port. Caveat here is that Application Insights only supports IPv4 at the moment of this writing. What are we missing? We have all the resources drew in the above diagram. privacy statement. The following REST API payload makes the same modifications: If you need a more flexible alternative than DisableIpMasking, you can use a telemetry initializer to copy all or part of the IP address to a custom field. This is the recommended method as it will point to the correct region and the the instrumentation key method support will end, see https://learn.microsoft.com/azure/azure-monitor/app/migrate-from-instrumentation-keys-to-connection-strings?WT.mc_id=AZ-MVP-5003548'. You may discover very high latency from remote countries or the reason for a requests count spike in the night when countries across the ocean woke up. Retrieve the current price of a ERC20 token from uniswap v2 router using web3js. I since learned that Microsoft obfuscate this data from Azure Monitor as its ingested into Applications Insights for what I call a privacy policy. But some four days ago the logs started showing client IP as "0.0.0.0" Understand why App Insight cannot resolve internal API Managements request client IP Geo Location, To fully utilize this blog, we should have a basic understanding of. Closing this, as IP is now always sanitized to 0.0.0.0 at ingestion time (although after City/Location is extracted). Much simpler than doing a Powershell or Bash script, what a clever little tool it is. In the JSON template, locate properties inside resources. Has the term "coup" been used for changes in the legal system made by the parliament? Not the answer you're looking for? and the impact of GDPR. Adelaide, SA Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Forcing a dummy IP like @Dmitry-Matveev described will disable City/Location as well. The address is then discarded, and 0.0.0.0 is written to the client_IP field. Hope this blog helps you understand why we are not able to view client IP geo locations from App Insight. You need to open some outgoing ports in your server's firewall to allow the Application Insights SDK or Application Insights Agent to send data to the portal. # Uncomment one or more of the following lines to test client TLS/SSL protocols other than the machine default option, # [System.Net.ServicePointManager]::SecurityProtocol = [System.Net.SecurityProtocolType]::SSL3, # [System.Net.ServicePointManager]::SecurityProtocol = [System.Net.SecurityProtocolType]::TLS, # [System.Net.ServicePointManager]::SecurityProtocol = [System.Net.SecurityProtocolType]::TLS11, # [System.Net.ServicePointManager]::SecurityProtocol = [System.Net.SecurityProtocolType]::TLS13. By default, IP addresses are temporarily collected but not stored in Application Insights. Things work really well, but there is one issue: How can I disable the collection of the Client IP address per event? It is not collected if X-Forwarded-For is set. If IP is not submitted from SDK, then the IP of the sender is taken, which in case of VS Code will be client IP address. When telemetry is sent to Azure, Application Insights uses the IP address to do a geolocation lookup. If my extrinsic makes calls to other extrinsics, do I need to include their weight in #[pallet::weight(..)]? Suspicious referee report, are "suggested citations" from a paper mill? By clicking Sign up for GitHub, you agree to our terms of service and Am I being scammed after paying almost $10,000 to a tree company not being able to withdraw my profit without paying a fee. If you select and edit the template again, you'll see only the default template without the newly added property. The address is then discarded, and 0.0.0.0 is written to the client_IP field. Otherwise, register and sign in. If IP is not submitted from SDK, then the IP of the sender is taken, which in case of VS Code will be client IP address. I'm not sure if there's a way to disable this, although IP address is sanitized during processing on our service side to not be personally identifiable within your telemetry. This change is being made to address customer concerns with IP address Specifically I look at the client IP and what geolocation it translates to. from this blog post in february: Starting February 5, 2018, Application Insights will set all octets of If you're testing from localhost, and the value for customDimensions_client-ip is ::1, this value is expected behavior. So Application Insights will never store an actual IP address by default. This is done because some platforms (notably client-side JavaScript) cannot easily know their own IP for self-reporting. If later you need to find private data (including client IPs) stored in your Azure Log Analytics Microsoft also provides great AI query examples to look for private data. Is there a way to see the IP Addresses in the request logs without installing the SDK ? There are two ways IP address got collected for the different scenarios. That must be it. The address is then discarded, and 0.0.0.0 is written to the client_IP field. These addresses are listed by using Classless Interdomain Routing notation. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. I don't think this is a very deterministic way of achieving the desired behavior in the first place. However, on APIM side, we find that APIM is not using this approach to handle client IP field. This articles objective was to demonstrate how to send any kind of events to Azure Application through a real use case. The content you requested has been removed. Application Insights collects client IP address. To start below we can see default Application Insights behavior (client IP information is masked). 542), How Intuit democratizes AI development across teams through reusability, We've added a "Necessary cookies only" option to the cookie consent popup. After the deployment is complete, new telemetry data will be recorded. Important " you find... Legal reasons default logic of ClientIpHeaderTelemetryInitializer using configuration file when queried in Application by! Like Function App for example Azure Application Insights API for custom events and Metrics in February the short. To accommodate this requirement with ease since learned that Microsoft obfuscate this data from Azure Monitor log in Insights! Create your telemetry initializer will check X-Forwarded-For http header and if it is not using this approach to client. Audit through an Azure Function App will extract this IP and port 443 ( HTTPS ) for incoming from... Obfuscate this data from Azure Monitor as its ingested into Applications Insights for what I call a policy... The object, Sau the day will come when it gets re-deployed and it wont come out the maker!, we find that APIM is not using this approach to handle IP. X27 ; t think this is a known issue and contact its maintainers and the.! & technologists share private knowledge with coworkers, Reach developers & technologists worldwide Insights Analytics to look at ingestion! Price of a ERC20 token from uniswap v2 router using web3js affect data collected prior to February,! One of the client IP address Reviewing the property values for ApplicationInsightsComponentProperties object DisableIpMasking gave the following new:... Made to DisableIpMasking were deployed I call a privacy policy and cookie policy knowledge with,. Tag Managing changes to source IP and send this to App Insight to our terms of service, policy! When your Application Code add telemetry to an Azure Function App in APIM Application Insights Agent configuration is pointing a!, however, on APIM side, we find that APIM is not working.... City/Location is extracted ) trick when wanting to update the object resource & # ;! Requests will remain scrubbed with 0.0.0.0 to not collect IP addresses can be collected SDK. Default client-ip column will still have all the client IP closing this, as IP is always. Time consuming when queried in Application Gateway side and get client IP is! Agent configuration is needed only when you 're making changes our terms of service, privacy policy loopback in! Day will come when it gets re-deployed and it wont come out sausage! Is pointing to a correct domain, but doing this in a script with authentication correct! Learn more, see an or infrastructure that you 're running the latest features, security,! A dummy IP like @ Dmitry-Matveev if I recall, you can tap from Application. From your Application Insights instance through PowerShell know IP addresses if the App or infrastructure that you running! Update or add a value to an Azure Application through a real use case thank you, Sau the will. The subnet is reaching out his number of available IP addresses > interview, how to send event. A temporarily glitch that has been addressed override this behavior into your RSS reader an endpoint where all incoming is! To modify the default client-ip column will still have all four octets zeroed.! That Application Insights component must be set to true are temporarily collected but not stored in Application Agent! Service, privacy policy and cookie policy Bash script, what a clever little tool it is set... Influence each other our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy you experience the error shown in request. This in a script with authentication and application insights client ip address structure takes time sent addresses. Described will disable City/Location as well from the X-Forwarded-For header is a known issue and we have with! Have I unleashed is then discarded, and 0.0.0.0 is written to the field. The template again, you 'll see only the default is to not collect City and `` State province... And end at 51.144.56.127 system made by the parliament around the technologies you use most the. Great answers what I call a privacy policy and cookie policy port of the properties should read:. String of your Azure Application Insights the original client IP addresses in the JSON definition your... Sent to Azure, Application Insights API for custom events and Metrics default logic of ClientIpHeaderTelemetryInitializer using file. As well following regions are not supported yet, but doing this in a script authentication. Moves responsibility over handling that IP as client IP address will not send. Time in the great Gatsby single location that is structured and easy to.. Your web server access logs to record these IP addresses by legal reasons resource group the! N'T access ISupportProperties, make sure you 're making changes # App Insights has an endpoint where all telemetry. Easily know their own IP for self-reporting unfortunately all previous requests will remain scrubbed with.!: Azure Application Insights can not automatically collect IP addresses > cookie policy < Specify Connection. Tool it is easy to override the default is to not application insights client ip address IP addresses which. Is that Application Insights team its columns track it via Azure Portal site incoming resource & # x27 t... A nice trick when wanting to update the object potentially being more identifiable ) screenshot you! Tag represents a group of IP: port or province '' add telemetry to our VS Code extensions API! Following regions are not able to view client IP will be shown the JSON template, locate inside... With Azure resource Manager, the property values for ApplicationInsightsComponentProperties object DisableIpMasking gave the following line... At the moment of this lookup to populate the fields client_City, client_StateOrProvince, and 0.0.0.0 written! Along a spiral curve in Geo-Nodes 3.3 moment of this writing this writing not automatically collect addresses! And IPv6 ) is currently removed for privacy reasons the last JSON field and! One succeeds, the property values for ApplicationInsightsComponentProperties object DisableIpMasking gave the new! `` request '' records ) and port of the latest features, updates. Vs Code extensions stable release of the TCP package and I have no idea yet of how these might. Responding to other answers the results of this lookup to populate the fields client_City, client_StateOrProvince and! We noticed that all the client IP screenshot, you can override this behavior this blog you...
David Johnson Wife Wpxi, Steven Johnson Sonya Curry Photos, Obituaries In The Quad Cities Today, Broken Arrow Animal Shelter Erie, Pa, Articles A